-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 8
Closed
Labels
chap-bindingsLanguage Bindings Chapter CommitteeLanguage Bindings Chapter CommitteeerrataErrata items for the previous MPI StandardErrata items for the previous MPI Standardpassed final votePassed the final formal votePassed the final formal votescheduled readingReading is scheduled for the next meetingReading is scheduled for the next meetingwg-fortranFortran Working GroupFortran Working Group
Milestone
Description
Problem
The constants MPI_STATUS_SIZE
, MPI_SOURCE
, MPI_TAG
, and MPI_ERROR
are specifically not defined in C.
Proposal
Add MPI_F_STATUS_SIZE
, MPI_F_SOURCE
, MPI_F_TAG
, and MPI_F_ERROR
constants in C. The F
in the names emphasizes that these are equivalent values to the already-defined-in-Fortran constants.
Note that the _SOURCE
, _TAG
, and _ERROR
constants are 1 less than their Fortran counterparts (since they are offsets into an array, and Fortran and C differ in their handling of array offsets).
Changes to the Text
- Add
MPI_F_STATUS_SIZE
up in chapter 2/terms and conditions - Add the other
MPI_F_
constants in chapter 18/language bindings
Corresponding PRs:
- MPI 3.x: https://github.com/mpi-forum/mpi-standard/pull/271
- PDF: mpi-report-pr271-3449c7f2d948906ef6d66478974dec55e0b541c5.pdf
- Changes:
- p15:37 (terms and conventions, listing of constants)
- p688:30-34 (Fortran bindings/status section)
- p704:6, 14-19 (update constant tables in A.1.1)
- p837:31-33 (changelog)
- MPI 4.x: https://github.com/mpi-forum/mpi-standard/pull/270
- PDF: mpi-report-pr270-266490d597c55671f7e6bb78380f2bcdae97c1bc.pdf
- Changes:
- p15:37 (terms and conventions, listing of constants)
- p758:33-37 (Fortran bindings/status section)
- p774:6, 14-19 (updated constant tables in A.1.1)
- p915:31-33 (changelog)
Impact on Implementations
Add MPI_F_STATUS_SIZE
, MPI_F_SOURCE
, MPI_F_TAG
, and MPI_F_ERROR
constants in mpi.h
.
Impact on Users
Users can allocate INTEGER-style Fortran statuses in C and properly read their values.
References
https://lists.mpi-forum.org/pipermail/mpiwg-fortran/2020-September/003584.html
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
chap-bindingsLanguage Bindings Chapter CommitteeLanguage Bindings Chapter CommitteeerrataErrata items for the previous MPI StandardErrata items for the previous MPI Standardpassed final votePassed the final formal votePassed the final formal votescheduled readingReading is scheduled for the next meetingReading is scheduled for the next meetingwg-fortranFortran Working GroupFortran Working Group